No time nor money

The new qualitative, longitudinal study of the lives of fourteen artists from three English regions, Artists’ lives: ecologies for resilience illustrates how policies have successively marginalised artists’ position in the infrastructures and ‘ecology’ of the arts. As a result, artists at all development stages lack social status, this whether seeking mutuality in their arrangements with commissioners and employers or dedicated research and development support. 

In parallel and due to widespread adoption across the funded visual arts of commercial creative industries methods and terms, volumes of paid work have reduced and art opportunities have become less attractive for artists artistically and economically. As far as artists are concerned, arts policy’s ‘market economy’ approach has the effect of undermining their stated aspirations to demonstrate equity and inclusion across the arts. 

Narrow perspective

Resilience has been a strategic policy goal at Arts Council England since the government’s austerity period from 2010. Promoted as a key expectation but only for funded arts institutions, policy’s assumption is that resilience is a product of having sound business models, strong leadership and traditional forms of governance. However, adopting this narrow perspective has simplified the social scope and expectations of arts infrastructures and undermined artists’ ability to sustain art practices over time. Contrary to policy’s generic, conglomerated view of ‘creative practitioners’, visual artists’ expectations, social beliefs and life goals aren’t achieved through making endless pitches for short-term projects devised by arts managers and curators. Rather, artists’ quest for self-directed learning through personalised, developmental practices is best characterised as a dedicated, situated pursuit of creativity within a life-long process. 

“I believe the social value of artists comes from their pursuit of art practices over a life time and that there are many ways to think about and recognise mutuality and collaboration. By working small-scale and developing ways to show and share work in progress there’s a sense that artists become indigenous and engaged quite naturally in a place and in nurturing and growing things from the ground up.” Edward

In demonstrating that artists’ motives don’t lie in achieving traditional business growth and profitability nor creating employment for others, the new study confirms Virani and Orrù’s research into artists’ practices at SPACE Studios. Visual artists are intuitively programmed to ‘right scale’ through a preference to keep everything ‘in-house’ and manageable in scope and size, this rather than increasing resources or outsourcing production to meet prospective market demand as other creative businesses do. 

“Interior designers … say they want four of this size and six of that … those massive jobs [for] around 20 original pieces of work [to] pitch to a client. I probably get about three or four requests like that a year … [But] if something like that came [through] … when I’m [doing something else], it would be an absolute nightmare as I wouldn’t have space or time to make the work.” Susannah

Contemporary visual arts infrastructures have been in lock-step with government policy and public funding parameters since 2020. They have wholeheartedly adopted creative industries principles where the ambition for the work is to be original, novel and innovative and achieve a measurable ‘market exchange value’ of some kind. As a result, any work or commission offer to an artist from most funded arts organisations is designed to involve as little institutional financial outlay as possible while trading on artists’ emotional need to make artistic progress. 

“Arts commissioners don’t seem to really understand what artists want and need to achieve with art practices and in society, nor do they get the precarity of working freelance. With one-off opportunities, artists only ever have a transitory relationship with an organisation so the artist’s tendency is always going to be to max out the budget. We put in loads more hours than the money allows for, just to fit in everything on the list and get something out of it for ourselves too. What I’d really like to see are more artist-friendly attitudes permeating across the visual arts, so that things aimed at artists aren’t all about delivering immediate ‘outcomes’.” Cora

Extractivist business models

Survival of commercial and subsidised visual arts organisations is now reliant on maintaining extractivist business models, this initially due to austerity but now a response to the even harsher post pandemic circumstances for arts and culture since. Arts organisations’ assumption that all but a discrete core of employed staff can be treated as freelance is central to the normalising of insecure contracts and creation of fragmented work and income patterns for artists. Success for arts organisations – including maintaining credible business plans for trustees and funders – has become reliant on a steady flow of cheap, flexible, skilled freelancers on a ‘just in time’ basis. In such a situation, it’s the artists who present as acquiescent, willingly reactive and grateful for what they are given more likely to get work.

“It seems employers don’t understand the difference between freelance and employed work. Their maths doesn’t take account of basic things like [needing enough] pay for holiday and pension contributions. It’s about what’s valued really – these people and institutions aren’t valuing what experienced creative people bring in.” Francis

But failure in arts organisations of the ‘mixed income’ business model presents a considerable threat to artists’ practices and livelihoods. This is because artists’ residency, workshop, exhibition and commission opportunities take place within funding dependent public engagement programmes, with delivering the work commonly appointed on ‘just in time’ call-out and freelance terms. 

“I’ve always been prepared to work hard but …even … in the commercial sector, I’m finding the pay hasn’t kept up with the cost-of-living rise. So, I do wonder how women artists can possibly make a living once they have kids. How are we meant to do that?” Tanya 

Whether public or commercial, visual arts environments positively discourage artists from being overt about specific personal circumstances and longer-term economic needs. It’s ‘not cool’ for artists to assert the level of fee rates and contractual terms they actually need. 

“There’s a type of artist that institutions … believe they can hire for cheap, often justifying it by referencing [out-of-date] guidelines. However, those guidelines aren’t … applicable for someone like me with over 25 years of experience.” Mid-career artist

The result of this institutional norm for artists is lack of career progression through art practices, this because work opportunity from arts organisations can range from something of high career significance on one occasion to work at a far lower level the next. Furthermore, current systems to present and authenticate the visual arts as a social benefit have the effect of privileging those artists with the financial, social and educational means to withstand the structural imbalance and economic uncertainties. Arrangements in which individuals must take opportunities as, when and where they can are transactional and by nature, are less supportive of a particular individual’s career development. 

Pitching for work

 But to maintain any credentials in the visual arts ecology, artists must continually pitch for –  and in the main fail to get – competitively offered and relatively low-value opportunities. Although they reasonably desire concentrated periods of R&D, such ambitions are tempered with recognition that grant application processes are not only lengthy, exacting and frustrating but have exceedingly low success rates. Not accounted for in such a situation is the 20% neurodivergence in the creative industries, with the associated dyslexia and dyscalculia impacting adversely on individuals’ basic communications skills including when making grant applications and project proposals. 

“When you’re writing applications, it seems that you have to be able to read between the lines. I’m dyslexic so struggle with words and I’m not good with numbers either. Even the questions in application forms are in a language I just wouldn’t write in.” Emily

While this research articulates the artists’ plea for better, more accessible R&D resources, the Government’s Creative Industries Sector Plan sees visual arts development as a minor consideration catered for by enhancing arts buildings. CVAN’s 2025 advocacy statement Framing the Future: The Political Case for Strengthening the Visual Arts Ecosystem continues this theme by arguing for increased investment in artists’ studio buildings. However a significant finding from this research is that regardless of career stage, artists are currently spending little time in their studios. Although they commonly work long daily hours, six days a week, most of their time goes to doing the non-art related jobs that provide just enough income for living and art practice costs, including studio rents. 

“I probably average twelve hours a month in my studio – a tiny fraction of what it was before the Covid and post pandemic situation of lack of commissions and funding and cost-of-living crisis. I’m teaching in two art schools in different towns but the workload [means] … my 2 day a week job takes 4 days … and there are many weeks where I just don’t get to the studio at all.” Mid-career artist in the Midlands

Rather than the 28-days annual statutory holiday allocation for arts employees, any ‘time off’ for artists is most often an occasional long weekend, a week visiting family or combined with something art related. 

“I’ve not been on a long holiday for probably about seven or eight years. The problem is the cost of things now. It’s just so hard to prioritise that with everything else.” Susannah

As advocacy lead for the visual arts sector, CVAN asserts that “every component plays a role in sustaining a vibrant – and genuinely world-leading – cultural landscape”. But this ecology’s quality is diminished all the time most artists suffer the human lack of personal ‘downtime’ and any sustained refreshment, which impact adversely on their emotional health and well-being as well as the quality of their work and multiple social contributions.

Credit

First published in Art Monthly 490, November 2025

References

DCMS (2025) Creative Industries Sector Plan 

CVAN (2025) Framing the Future: The Political Case for Strengthening the Visual Arts Ecosystem