Cracking up 

Launched April 2020, the DCMS Select Committee inquiry sought evidence on Covid-19’s immediate and likely long-term impacts on the workings of sectors under the department’s remit. By collecting ideas and propositions for evolving these beyond the pandemic, the inquiry intended to evidence the effectiveness of government and arms-length bodies’ emergency responses and inform future policy.

The inquiry’s first report in July 2020 considered some 660 written submissions and oral evidence provided March – July 2020. The committee in sitting was ‘struck by the ‘dire situations … of so many who feel they … have fallen through the cracks of the Government’s response to Covid-19’ (House of Commons, 2020:8). 

The plight of performing arts freelancers immediately affected when theatres and venues closed in the first lockdown was well-documented within the inquiry itself, on social media and in the national press including The Guardian (2020). This analysis responds to a gap in knowledge about the pandemic’s impacts on the practices and livelihoods of visual artists as a distinctive section of the creative freelance workforce. 

The weight and appeal of evidence on Covid-19’s impact on performing arts livelihoods is apparent in the committee’s first report which stated: ‘[T]he performing arts need a sector-specific recovery deal that includes continued workforce support measures, including enhanced measures for freelancers and small companies’. However, traditional enabling frameworks for performing arts, including professional and economic exchanges between actors and theatres and musicians and concert halls, aren’t mirrored in the visual arts. In the former, Equity and the Musicians Union attract substantial memberships and provide collective bargaining and guidance for members and employers including around payment levels and contractual terms relevant to the variety of performing arts work. These bodies have authority to advocate to employers, arts and cultural sectors and policymakers for improvements to members’ social and economic status. In contrast, visual arts representative bodies and unions have consistently lacked membership levels and clout to speak for artists and protect their rights by influencing employers’ behaviour, including on payment terms.

Moreover, the working environment for this distinctive sub-section is chronically under-examined. The breadth of visual artists’ practices is inadequately accounted for in the statistical frameworks for capturing and characterising sectoral workforce development and career needs (Jackson and Jordan, 2005; CAMEO, 2019). Definitions of visual artist are broadly-based and self-defined (TBR, 2018a) and artists take a variety of approaches to pursuit of art practices (CAMEO, 2019), this demonstrated by the range of social, cultural and economic values attached to them (Henry et al, 2021). 

Artists’ practices encompass creating paintings, sculptures, drawings and photography for exhibition and sale in gallery and alternative settings, visually based live art performance and digital and multi-media installations, and participatory, socially engaged and collectively realised art practices in community settings. Gallery or dealer representation provides a small percentage of the artist constituency with career development and economic security. Charitable and publicly funded arts organisations predominantly offer artists one-off, short-term commissions and opportunities intended to deliver audience engagement and other social and community-based impacts (Jones, 2019). 

The commentary of this review acknowledges the peculiar nature of the visual arts working environment. It starts by characterising artists’ working lives and goes on to identify core tensions in working relationships between artists and visual arts infrastructures. It continues by drawing out approaches to, and methods for, evolving an inclusive, productive arts ecology for the future. The conclusion demonstrates a polarity in arts industry perspectives for achieving this and with cross-reference to related literatures, indicates where systemic infrastructural change might provide a more supportive visual arts ecology for artists’ practices, social status and livelihoods in future. 

Research questions and method 

Aligned with the DCMS inquiry format, research questions were (1) What were the immediate effects of Covid-19 on artists’ lives? (2) How did the pandemic impact on visual arts infrastructures? and (3) What are the features and attributes of an inclusive arts ecology and environment for artists’ practices and livelihoods?. Study data was selected from 900 written submissions 18 May-15 July 2020 to the inquiry. Search terms including artists, freelance, visual arts, galleries, arts organisations and studios provided 46 for detailed analysis. An initial coding process drew out patterns in the data including synergies and divergences in terms of definitions of, and conditions for, infrastructural efficacy and workforce resilience. Clustering, condensing and reflecting on this material enabled the substantive threads to emerge in a review that includes cross-reference to related data and literatures 

Commentary 

This narrative identifies the core characteristics of, and frictions within, artists’ working conditions prior to and during the pandemic.

1 Characterising artists’ lives

* Visual artists’ distinctive contributions aren’t captured by instruments for measuring impacts of the arts on society.

Artists are ‘natural innovators’ whose practices and approaches typically respond to changing, new and ‘alternative’ contexts (Art Hub Studios). Visual artists who produce ‘original content’ (British Copyright Council) are valued for capacity to ‘adapt most swiftly and economically’, for example by moving quickly to deliver work online (Calderdale MBC) and making ‘pure digital products’ (Birmingham Museums Trust). It is ‘professional D/deaf and disabled artists … [who] make some of the most extraordinary and high-quality arts and culture’ (Arts Council England, What Next?).

‘The spark of creativity, empathy, courage and compassion, inclusivity and individuality … unique to artists and arts professionals has never been more valuable ….’ (Creative Arts East)

Positioned within a ‘pipeline of small, community, experimental [activities] and emerging practice’ (Paul Hamlyn Foundation), artists’ endeavours are considered vital to the nation’s global economic success and grassroots and social well-being. From this view, artists’ livelihood and development prospects are perceived as inextricably intertwined with the aspirations and fortunes of the ‘subsidised arts sector [which acts as the] talent development and inspirational pipeline to our global economic …. success’ (West Midland Culture Response Unit). Arts Council England’s (ACE) talent development policy locates arts institutions as ‘traditional gatekeepers of culture’. It is arts institutions’ responsibility to capture artists’ worth for society and maintain the international brand image of the arts by working with practitioners who are ‘cross-national and international workers’ (ACE, What Next?). From this stance, making a ‘social argument for a national blueprint for cultural renewal across four countries’ is a natural development (What Next?). 

In contrast, artists’ creative contributions reflective of place-specific variations and identity are vital to realising localised cultural development aspirations and aiding civic cohesion within place-based bodies and consortia (Haringey Culture Board, Creative Kernow, Torbay Culture). This approach safeguards and values grassroots contributions by specialist, freelance artists who are ‘often the leaders of innovation’ (Leeds Culture Trust). In particular, artists pursuing localised social practices are positioned ‘in the space left when youth, education and social services provisions decline or are cut’ (Curious Minds) and in delivery of the school art curriculum (Engage). Ethnically diverse practitioners in learning and development roles are ‘most frequently found working in non-venue based arts’, contributing to civic engagement and arts education within local communities (Inc Arts). 

Bottom-up infrastructures nurturing ‘home-grown’ talent generate national and international creative exports such as Mark Jenkin’s BAFTA-winning film BAIT, written and directed in Cornwall (Creative Kernow). In such instances, artists are perceived as catalysts for local creative cultures, their creativity forming the ‘means of encouraging personal development … and supporting social cohesion and civic awareness’ (Art Hub Studios, Artwork Wales, Brighton & Hove Council, Leeds Culture Trust). 

* Artists’ demographics and work patterns compound inequalities and disadvantage. 

The creative industries’ economic success depends on a continuous supply of flexible, low-paid freelance labour and portfolio work patterns (Florida, 2002; Banks and Hesmondhalgh, 2009). This low-paid self-employed labour base forms 47-70% of the cultural and arts workforce (Wallis and Raalte, What Next?, ACE). At 77%, self-employment levels are high amongst visual artists (Jones, 2019:181), rising to 98% amongst illustrators (Association of Illustrators). 

Economic precarity is the ‘human cost’ for self-employed individuals who lack security and employment protections enjoyed by permanent staff (What Next?, Wallis and Raalte, O’Brien, Artwork Wales, Curious Minds). This is particularly the case for over-represented sections of the arts workforce including females, those with invisible disabilities, and individuals from BAME (Black, Asian and Ethnic Minority) backgrounds (Parents in Performing Arts, Inc Arts, Freeman and Morris).

Prior research gives visual artists an average annual income of £16,150 from all sources, with £6,000 from art sources and only 7% earning more than £20,000 (TBR, 2018b:8). An artist’s typical ‘mixed income model’ comprises 33% sales, 29% teaching, 16% cultural freelancing, 13% non-art, 5% in grants and 4% from cultural employment (Acme). Work portfolios include self-employed aspects such as commissions and exhibitions, employment through teaching, gallery education and community and participatory arts residencies and non-art related work on a casual or zero-hour contract basis (East Street Arts, Acme). 

The combination limits artists’ ability to build savings and reserves to manage unexpected circumstances (Artists Union England, West Midlands Culture Response Unit, Crafts Council) and for old age. Poor economic circumstances discourage newcomers from pursuing creative careers and reduce the ‘talent pool’ on which the overall economy of the arts relies (CAMEO, 2019; New Art West Midlands, 2019) which delays workforce diversification (East Street Arts, West Midlands Culture Response Unit, Croydon Culture Network, Paul Hamlyn Foundation, What Next?). 

‘Lack of future work opportunity will deplete cultural talent and cultural activity as creative people leave to work in less precarious employment.’ (Torbay Culture)

Low pay in cultural and creative occupations exacerbates systemic gender and class inequalities (O’Brien, Wallis and Raalte). Financial uncertainty and juggling work and childcare are substantial barriers for females who form the majority in cultural sector roles and are more likely to be care-givers (Association of Illustrators, Parents in Performing Arts, Torbay Culture, Creative Scotland). Disabled and neurodivergent artists and those from BAME backgrounds are particularly vulnerable in vicarious employment conditions (CVAN, Paul Hamlyn Foundation). 

* Individuals carry the burden of emotional and economic precarity.

Financial hardship and lack of investment in and poor tailoring of sector-specific support infrastructures impact adversely on artists’ emotional stability and confidence to manage uncertainty and sustain practices over the long-term (Plymouth Culture, Creative Scotland, Creative Kernow, Paul Hamlyn Foundation, Association of Illustrators, CVAN, Croydon Culture Network, Wallis and Raalte). The well-being and resilience of hundreds of artists is reliant on appropriate access to opportunity and practical support to scope and produce new work (Croydon Culture Network, Art Hub Studios, Acme, East Street Arts). Current visual arts policy and development strategies have ‘badly overlooked the basic level of [artists’] production, without which nothing else is possible’ (Acme). 

Poor mental health and social isolation are exacerbated when personalised supportive networks are absent. Current patchy or non-existent support structures including to reliable, accessible studio provision, lack of clarity about artistic development and livelihood prospects and poorly rewarded work in over-competitive environments contribute to poor mental health and emotional well-being amongst visual artists. Freelancers’ mixed income and portfolio working model makes them ‘uniquely vulnerable’ because individuals carry the ‘invisible burden of all the economic risk’ (Wallis and Raalte). 

2. Impact of Covid-19 on artists’ lives

* The pandemic presented an immediate threat to artists’ livelihoods and well-being.

Visual artists’ current and prospective commissioned freelance or employed work in arts settings ceased on lockdown, as did opportunity for work in arts and cultural organisations’ public programmes and much other subsidiary and non-art-related employment. An ACE assumption was that half of all individual artists wouldn’t be able to survive in the long-term without major financial supportive interventions. Two fifths of visual artists and nearly three-quarters of illustrators lost work from March 2020 (CVAN, Artists Union England, Association of Illustrators). 

Artists’ immediate and multiple income losses arose from a combination of cancellation of forthcoming work contracts for subsidised and commercial bodies, loss of direct and indirect sales, commissioners cancelling or delaying future work opportunity, loss of secondary earnings including from employment in art teaching and participatory arts (Creative Scotland, Curious Minds, Brighton & Hove Council) and curtailment of application to regular grant schemes for individuals. Not all cultural organisations honoured payment for cancelled contracts (Creative Arts East, Croydon Culture Network). 

Against predictions of a 50-90% annual income loss (ACE, Brighton and Hove Council), more than three-fifths of visual artists anticipated this as 80-100% (Acme). Over two-fifths of BAME creative individuals anticipated a 75% income drop (Inc Arts). Three-fifths of makers expected to lose £5,000 and nearly three quarters of illustrators £1-3,000 (Crafts Council, Association of Illustrators). Closure of galleries (71%) and markets and fairs (64%) had the greatest impact on craft makers’ businesses (Crafts Council). The pandemic additionally escalated artists’ mental fragility, with many without a support network ‘fee[ling] isolated and overwhelmed by loss of income, [their] personal resilience impacted by overbearing demand to build this rapidly’ (Croydon Culture Network). Emotional precarity was particularly felt by disabled individuals and those with underlying health conditions, amongst BAME artists and the clinically vulnerable advised to shield (Inc Arts, What Next?, Artists Union England, Freeman and Morris). 

‘A high proportion of D/deaf and disabled artist community is self-isolating or shielding…. [with] significant problems for some in accessing personal assistance and basic support…’ (What Next?)

* Inappropriate eligibility criteria prevented many visual artists from accessing emergency funding. 

Government provided financial aid to employees through the Job Retention Scheme (JRS) or furlough, with the Self-employed Income Support Scheme (SEISS) intended to assist freelancers. Although ‘a large number of individuals were expected to apply’ for governmental financial support (ACE), eligibility criteria for SEISS and ACE emergency funds presented a significant barrier to take-up by visual artists (CVAN, Engage, Artists Union England, What Next?). Most freelance visual artists were excluded because both schemes failed to consider the particularity of visual artists’ employment status patterns and income types, including unpredictability of income and expenditure year-on-year (East Street Arts, Leeds Culture Trust, DACS, Calderdale Metropolitan Borough Council, Artists Union England, Wallis and Raalte, Acme, Paul Hamlyn Foundation). 

It was ‘inevitable many freelancers would be ineligible and disproportionately affected … placing the freelance community under overwhelming financial, physical and mental strain.’ (Plymouth Culture)

To apply for any of first three SEISS rounds, individual applicants must have been self-employed for three years and earning half or more annual income from ‘creative freelance work’. Ineligible individuals included those self-employed with PAYE as the major income source, early career freelancers lacking 2018/19 tax returns and others taking career breaks, maternity leave or paid through Limited Company dividends (What Next?, Crafts Council, DACS). Financial disadvantage was greatest amongst visual artists as three quarters were unable to apply (Acme), and for disabled, ND and BAME arts practitioners (CVAN). 

‘A high proportion of the D/deaf and disabled artist community … faced financial hardship’ and other systemic failures. (What Next?)

Other extenuating economic circumstances peculiar to visual artists weren’t accounted for. SEISS’s three-month time lag for pay-outs didn’t recognise self-employed artists’ lack of reserves and savings (Crafts Council, Artists Union England). By using profit levels rather than annual turnover as financial need calculator, SEISS failed to account for the high levels of speculative working characteristic of contemporary visual arts, where artists’ costs and expenses for production of new work may take up to two years to recoup (Artists Union England). In addition, funding based on profit-level criteria is a blunt instrument unlikely to provide financial support at levels artists need to ‘keep living and creating the work our art market depends on’ (DACS). 

There was an overall lack of non-competitive funding and grants to enable keep freelancers going and continuing to make work over an extended pandemic period (Brighton & Hove Council, NECP, What Next?). Whereas the government’s blanket SEISS grants were non-discriminatory, ACE’s £20m one-off emergency grants up to £2,500 for individuals of took an ‘elitist approach’ (Creative Kernow) and were assessed as ‘unnecessarily bureaucratic’ and ‘over-competitive’ (CVAN).

‘[It was] a lottery-style grant …Those who were … successful … then had their Universal Credit denied as the grant was part of the means testing applied to the benefit.’ (Artists Union England)

ACE further limited applications to individuals with a ‘track record [of] working in the ‘publicly funded culture sector’ able to evidence financial losses directly due to Covid-19 work cancellations (Creative Kernow, Artists Union England). Just over 2,000 visual arts practitioners benefitted from these emergency grants although it is unclear how many were visual artists as reporting was in broad categories and numerical only. The visual arts cohort could be reasonably assumed to include freelance curators, visual arts educators and animators, visual arts managers and commissioners and visual artists. 

3. Impact on arts infrastructures 

* The pandemic caused immediate, substantial disruption to arts organisations’ business models. 

Encouraged by government and funding policies, arts organisations’ business models typically augment regular revenue funding with significant commercial and philanthropic income and occasional grants, making them highly vulnerable to unexpected shocks. The more successful arts organisations had been at expanding trading and earned income strands and fundraising, the greater the pandemic’s impact (ACE, Paul Hamlyn Foundation, Creative Scotland, North Tyneside Council, Haringey Culture Board). Half of England’s and Scotland’s arts organisations were assessed unviable without government or other intervention (ACE, Creative Scotland). 

Pandemic circumstances were forecast to irrevocably change culture because many existing arts organisations, including ‘some of the most celebrated venues’, would have to close permanently (Torbay Culture, Newcastle City Council). Government and arts emergency provisions appeared to underestimate that the arts infrastructure’s ‘reset’ and recovery would take at least two to three years or longer, with damage to arts organisations’ business models potentially irreversible (Paul Hamlyn Foundation, North East Culture Partnership). 

Failure of arts organisations’ ‘mixed income’ business model has long-term implications for artists’ livelihoods. Freelance artists carry the greatest financial risk because contracted work and associated fees fall outside organisations’ core operational costs and depend on public programmes being run. In this respect, the pandemic caused Manchester Museums Partnership to reduce programme budgets by three-fifths. In terms of illustrating differing levels of emergency support for permanent staff and freelance labour, Creative Arts East (ACE Band 1 NPO) allocates 60% of a £500,000 turnover on business operating costs including PAYE salaries for nine full-time staff. 

While employees were eligible for government JRS, the organisation was responsible for honouring contracted fees to thirty artists and performers for cancelled public-facing work. Prioritising regularly funded institutions for immediate government and ACE financial support failed to recognise and quantify the contribution of hyper-local and community-level activities to the arts sector (Paul Hamlyn Foundation, Inc Arts, Artwork Wales, North Tyneside Council, Creative Kernow, Leeds Culture Trust). 

‘There is … a danger that access to the arts is undermined by a rush to support the bigger national institutions – there should be a compact attached to any settlement that places as much value on the work of community engagement and education practitioners as [it] does blockbusters’. (Paul Hamlyn Foundation)

Little evidence exists of cross-sector working to tackle a systemic flaw threating the sector’s future overall vibrancy (Plymouth Culture). The ‘talent pipeline’ is fractured when commissioning programmes in larger organisations retract while responsive, small and nimble, micro, co-operative, artist-led and community-based organisations and ventures that act at speed to provide help (Curious Minds, Sheffield City Region Mayoral Combined Authority, Artworks Wales) ‘will struggle [to get] through the …crisis’ (North Tyneside Council).

* Artists’ circumstances and diversity of arts contributions were under-represented in government and arts policy consultations on emergency measures.

Presentation of, and public engagement in, contemporary visual arts depend on a critical mass of primary creators, including visual artists, pursuing practices persistently over a life cycle. In the pandemic, individuals’ voices and experiences were on the periphery of consultations on the scope and nature of emergency support (East Street Arts, Acme, Artists Union England). In particular, the Government’s Cultural Renewal Taskforce lacked representation from those with wider arts knowledge including in socially engaged, participatory and community arts practices and from others with ‘lived experience of diversity’ (What Next?). The result was that measures intended to be supportive of freelance visual artists were inadequate to the size of the task, inappropriate to the particularity of their circumstances and too slow to materialise.

‘Whilst in the same storm, not everyone is in the same boat, with widening inequalities opening up between individuals and organisations’. (What Next?)

Liaising and communicating with the broad spectrum of sectoral activity regionally and nationally should be a key function of central and arm’s length arts organisations (North East Culture Partnership). However, consultations to frame suitable emergency measures occurred through, and were limited by, the knowledge of those already on government and arts funders’ radars. In particular, ACE relied too heavily on intelligence from its portfolio of regularly funded organisations (Plymouth Culture, North East Culture Partnership, Calderdale Metropolitan Borough Council). 

Lack of representation by and for individuals widened existing gaps in DCMS, Treasury and ACE’s understanding of the nuance of the arts sector’s make-up, including differing workforce contributions and diverse needs. The outcome was a slow, inadequate response to the specific economic and social circumstances of individual creative freelancers on whom the sector relies (Creative Kernow, Torbay Culture, Curious Minds, Artwork Wales, South Tyneside Council).

4. Evolving an inclusive, productive arts ecology 

* Recognising the diverse values attached to artists’ contributions to society is dependent on redistribution of power and resources.

Forty years of policy at ACE and predecessor Arts Council of Great Britain concentrated investment on permanent arts organisations and associated job creation as prime means of developing arts infrastructures and relational ecologies that foster social cohesion. Dependent on the extent and quality of interrelations (Gross and Wilson, 2019), sustainable ecologies are characterised by mutual flourishing arising from inclusive cross-fertilisation and co-development between actors (Capra, 2004; Banks, 2022). Pandemic circumstances highlighted failure of ‘trickle-down’ policy and vertically framed arts ecologies to cater for and capitalise on assets from messy, dynamic interrelationships and unorthodox career and content origination (Holden, 2015; Markusen et al, 2011). 

Emergency measures highlighted funders’ lack of understanding of the value of granular grassroots activities including the social significance of visual artists’ nuanced and diverse contributions to communities and localities), this due to limited inclusion of small-scale and individual endeavours in arts policies since 2010.  Some aspects of the arts sector asserted long-term security as wholly dependent on maintaining or increasing levels of government funding to ACE as arm’s length agency. Pursuit of ACE’s ten-year Let’s Create policy (2020) is cited as essential to sectoral and national recovery (What Next?, Durham County Council, Sheffield City Region Mayoral Combined Authority). From this perspective, England’s cohort of National Portfolio Organisations (NPOs) are its most important feature. These ‘build prosperous places and strong, cohesive communities … attracting visitors, driving outside investment to local communities and creat[ing] jobs’ (ACE). 

Future strategic improvements centre on strengthening existing frameworks and widening the remit of ‘blockbuster’ and ‘bricks and mortar’ institutions by repositioning them as ‘civic and community hubs’ (Paul Hamlyn Foundation). In this respect, nationally focused policy delivery of arts innovation and quality are measurable derivatives of engagement between permanent institutions and the ‘cross-national and international’ individuals with whom they choose to work (ACE), with sustained relationships with ‘local artists’ of lesser significance (Manchester Museums Partnership). 

The alternative perspective however is that dedicated focus on larger institutions undervalues the strategic significance of the wider, rich, complex arts ecology lying ‘in the shadow of the larger players … [that] generates cultural activity beyond the … ‘narrow frame of the “arts”’ presented by those directly funded (Leeds Culture Trust, Croydon Culture Network). Sustained communication with and acknowledgement of activities outwith NPOs and strategic preservation of regional, sub-regional and micro-level cultural variation is asserted as vital to arts recovery (North East Culture Partnership). 

‘The arts ecology is delicate, and any support forthcoming must recognise the contribution of small, community, experimental and emerging practice as much as it does the drivers of economic growth – one does not exist without the other, and the wider creative industries are reliant on this pipeline.’ (Paul Hamlyn Foundation) 

Devolving arts policy and funding responsibility away from ACE offers fresh eyes on, and mechanisms for, ‘…reimagin[ing] the production of art and culture at hyperlocal, neighbourhood and community level’ (Durham County Council). In this respect, place-specific agents of change and civic leaders can be found amongst individual people and informal groupings embedded in their locale (Haringey Culture Board, Leeds Culture Trust, Brighton & Hove Council, Calderdale Metropolitan Borough Council, Creative Kernow, Arts Catalyst). The new financial models for arts and localised economies identified from such a policy sea-change project a future creative sector more representative of art form nuance, bespoke to place and cultural context, with agility to respond appropriately to external shocks (Simon Poulter, Plymouth Culture, Croydon Culture Network). 

‘The creative interventions community arts organisations provide are uniquely placed in responding quickly to … needs and ... will play a vital role in … mending our society’. (Creative Arts East)

ACE’s preference for delivering policy objectives predominantly through NPOs limits scope for developing alternative delivery methods that might strategically account for location and artform specificity. Substantial new investment via local authorities offers a granular ‘bottom up’, accountable long-term mechanism for sustaining localised ecologies and communities of interest. 

‘We need funding to be allocated differently coming out of the crisis than .. before … with a greater focus on communities’. (Croydon Culture Network)

Work commissioned direct from artists at the grassroots better understands and ‘respond[s] to [the] place and locality where knowledge and expertise exists’, with creative outcomes ‘relatable and instinctive’ (Calderdale Metropolitan Borough Council, Plymouth Culture, Durham County Council). Art imbued with a sense of place, reflective of local variations and specific impacts, is a prime contributor to sustaining vibrant, inclusive and diverse arts ecologies (Brighton and Hove Council, Calderdale Metropolitan Borough Council, Haringey Culture Board, Torbay Culture). In more rural areas, demand is high for conditions supportive of the range of creative and collective activities making distinctive contributions to local economic and social well-being (Creative Kernow). Such conceptualisations of inclusive, diverse arts production and distribution environments align with practitioner arguments for restructuring the funding system on equity grounds (Artists Union England). 

* Protecting individual practitioners’ rights within sustainable livelihoods is dependent on structural reforms.

Although national policy seeks to achieve equality and diversity across and through the arts, current remedial strategies inadequately account for all professional contributions to it. Limiting disadvantage is particularly pertinent in the face of unexpected shocks, such as the pandemic, which accentuate systemic faults. 

‘There is now an opportunity to imagine afresh what the arts are for and for whom, and how we can create equity across our sector that can celebrate the richness of our diverse stories and heritage…’ (Leeds Culture Trust)

ACE’s ambition to rebalance the permanent workforce’s demographic to align with national data is furthered through NPO funding agreements, measured by annual reviews and performance indicators. However, achieving lasting change is at risk when remedial measures in workforce development strategies exclude the many arts individuals on temporary or occasional contracts in smaller-scale and ad-hoc settings, and poor livelihood prospects restrict who gets to work in the arts (Inc Arts, Croydon Culture Network, What Next?, O’Brien, Parents in Performing Arts). Unexpected shocks such as the pandemic amplify baseline inequalities and illustrate urgent need for more imaginative corrective strategies (Leeds Culture Trust, Croydon Culture Network, Brighton & Hove Council, Inc Arts).

Achieving equality and diversity goals is better considered as business critical, affective across all aspects of the arts infrastructure and integral to all aspects of recruitment including freelance and occasional workers (Inc Arts, Creative Kernow). Improving artists’ economic circumstances, including closing the gender pay gap, requires universal acceptance across the funded arts of artists’ professional and social status. This includes enshrining individuals’ right to negotiate fair working conditions, contractual and remuneration terms supportive of their social realities (East Street Arts, Wallis and Raalte, Artists Union England, Parents in Performing Arts). 

Arts employees commonly benefit from workforce development opportunity within arts organisations’ commitment to cultural workforce diversity and equality. Neither ACE nor NPOs make a parallel commitment to resourcing the continuous professional development (CPD) for freelancers similarly vital to achieving this. Features to be addressed by future arts policies include ‘lack of investment in workforce skills’, ‘normalisation of non-standard recruitment practices’ and aligning organisational budgets and support structures for freelance contributors with their overall contribution to arts organisations’ resilience (Wallis and Raalte). 

* Remedies to artists’ precarities lie in strategic policy intervention. 

Artists’ economic resilience and social well-being over a life cycle is reliant on consistent and appropriate supportive interventions including individualised CPD, access to research and development (R&D) funding and affordable workspace. Known omissions in dedicated provision for visual artists range from entry-level skills acquisition to continuous upskilling to progress careers in changing environments (Leeds Culture Trust, Wallis and Raalte, Crafts Council, Croydon Culture Network, Creative Kernow). Personalised advice and upskilling are particularly pertinent for freelancers due to the pandemic’s ‘very particular challenges’ (What Next?, Association of Illustrators, Durham County Council, Torbay Culture). Notably, artists’ agility to deliver digital products as alternative to in-person engagement to aid the well-being of others was judged both a ‘lifeline to …. people including those shielding with long-term health conditions’ (What Next?) and of strategic value to creative businesses’ viability (Siepel et al, 2021). 

Conversely, artists without such skills lacked access to training to acquire them and to dedicated advice on replacing lost or redundant income strands with viable digital and virtual offers (Artists Union England, CVAN, Brighton & Hove Council). Moreover, the scant tangible support to ameliorate pandemic-related impacts on artists’ mental and physical health, including the consequences of ‘long Covid’ (Association of Illustrators, Artists Union England) affected their well-being (CVAN, 2021). Selected local recovery funds ensured some artists retained access to ‘meanwhile’ and group studio spaces. In other cases, artists’ poor mental health was triggered by being locked out of studios while rent debt accumulated, with eviction threats from commercial landlords (Newcastle City Council, Art Hub Studios, Acme, DACS). 

‘….whether or not [artists] experienced mental health concerns before lockdown, the pandemic was …. responsible for emergence or intensification of symptoms.’ (Dutton, 2021:9)

Government capital funding for property or long-term lease purchase to safeguard studio providers supports the lateral development trajectories of the diversity of artists and is a strategic benefit to contemporary visual arts in perpetuity (Acme). Government reform of self-employment law with extension of tax credits for training, protections of artists’ copyright and unilateral sectoral adoption of good working practices aligns to policy aspirations for fair pay for freelancers at rates reflective of their social realities (East Street Arts, Crafts Council, DACS, Artists Union England, Parents in Performing Arts). Increased ACE funding to a wider range of visual arts specific Sector Support Organisations (SSOs) would provide tailored support to larger numbers of artists.

‘[Invest in] organisations committed to supporting artists through studios, opportunities, advice and training [which] develop infrastructure and opportunities for artists … in the wider ecology including health, education, housing and the art sector’. (East Street Arts)

Increased funding to the more agile and responsive smaller-scale and artist-run ventures would provide many more artists with consistent, tangible support (Curious Minds, Plymouth Culture, East Street Arts) while contributing to localised initiatives for social and economic recovery in communities (Plymouth Culture). Note however it was such ventures that were amongst first casualties of ACE’s austerity cuts (Louise, 2011). Strategic devolution of arts funding to local and regional infrastructures for interventions specifically supportive of artists and small-scale creative developments offers holistic, sustainable support for many artists over a life cycle (Plymouth Culture, Creative Kernow). Targeted direct provisions including increased budgets for individual R&D grants and loans on less stringent terms than at present support artists’ resilience over the longer-term (Association of Illustrators, Crafts Council, DACS, Durham County Council, Newcastle City Council, North East Culture Partnership, Brighton & Hove Council, Artists Union England). 

Although budgets were later increased for ACE’s open-access grants for individual artistic replenishment Develop Your Creative Practice (DYCP) the scheme remains under-resourced, over-competitive and is more restrictive (Redmond, 2021). A limitation of ACE’s National Lottery Project Grants which by the funder’s admission lacked adequate financial resources to meet pandemic demands (ACE), is its privileging of entrepreneurial practices (Centre for Cultural Value, 2020). 

Conclusion

This review of Covid-19 impacts offers insight into formulation of future arts and cultural policy development by reconfirming visual artists’ particular vulnerability to unexpected shocks or ‘world events’ (Galloway et al, 2002). It aligns with related research showing that pandemic conditions exacerbated existing structural precarities for creative individuals (Comunian and England, 2020; Greer, 2021; Walmsley et al, 2022), including compounding workforce imbalances and discriminations (Eikhof, 2020; Connor, 2021). Emergency arts and cultural funding and support mechanisms failed to address the nature and complexity of creative employment patterns (Walmsley et al, 2022). Despite their creative agility being pivotal to sustaining organisations’ business models, because work arrangements typically lack the duty of care and social and economic rigours of statutory employment practices (Burns, 2017; Banks, 2017; Belfiore, 2021), freelancers ‘bore the brunt of the pain’ (Siepel et al, 2021). Later studies confirm that visual artists in particular lacked access to appropriate support to ameliorate pandemic impacts (CVAN, 2021). While just over a third benefitted from new digital work opportunity, most suffered major income loss in a creative sub-section disproportionately excluded from emergency funding (CVAN, 2021; Dutton, 2021). 

This study illustrates a polarity in perspectives for enabling productive, inclusive and equitable infrastructures arts ecology in future. ACE’s emergency recovery strategy privileged permanent and larger-scale institutions and certain kinds of management structure and business model at the expense of supporting the freelance precariat (Greer, 2021:235-6). This institutional perspective is premised on assumptions that strengthening existing policy implementation mechanisms remains the best way to resolve acknowledged discriminations in the arts, including lack of workforce diversity and freelancers’ economic inequality. Dominated by regularly funded organisations, the What Next? network similarly concluded that the key to future arts resilience lies in pursuit of ‘top down’ policies and trickle-down delivery hierarchies augmented by a ‘national blueprint for cultural renewal’ covering the UK’s four countries and all stakeholders. 

In direct contrast to preserving this status quo, many cultural, interest-group and place-specific fora, sector support bodies and some local authorities perceived pandemic circumstances as opportunity for root-and-branch reassessment and reshaping of the arts ecology’s workings. Refuting the future relevance of a ‘one size fits all’ approach, this rationale aligns with later analyses (Banks, 2022; Bernard et al, 2021; Walmsley et al, 2022). Shifting power, funding and economic accountability to the grassroots and small-scale acknowledges the strength of localised arts developments that ‘engag[e with] audiences and networks to experiment in doing things differently … which will create inspirational blueprints for [other] communities.’ (Creative Kernow). 

From this stance and echoing contemporaneous ‘levelling up’ arguments (Cooper, 2020; Sleaford et al, 2020), routes to sustainable arts recovery lie in systemic upheaval. Such strategies are concerned with forging an inclusive, productive and differently measured arts ecology more accommodating of divergent, localised social realities. Broadening definitions of arts development and growth gives equal weight to markers for, and measurement of, the environmental, social and economic well-being of all making the arts, ensuring human flourishing so that ‘everyone contributes [and] everyone gains’ (Banks, 2022). This methodology looks beyond prescriptive delineations for categorising and managing difference and disadvantage in current systems, providing scope for developing nuanced concepts to counter multiple discriminations (Hark and Villa, 2020). 

From this grassroots perspective, creating and sustaining healthy arts provisions are premised on replacing the status quo with responsive, particularised frameworks for arts resilience, including for individuals who are the principle creative players. Characterised by freedom, scope and power to create and recreate aspects and ‘hold[ing] open conditions in which connections can be made, experiences shared, skills developed and diverse practices of culture-making interact’ (Gross and Wilson, 2019), development assumes redundancy of some institutions and reimagined use of arts buildings. Sustainability is fostered by operating as mutually beneficial, inclusive ecosystems in which self-supporting and self-regenerating aspects grow and are empowered by purposeful interconnections between divergent elements, functions and behaviours (Capra, 2004; Bernard et al, 2021).

By fostering nuanced, sustained interplay across micro and transient structures and larger-scale and permanent organisations, these ‘bottom-up’ models equate resilience with conditions that are ‘attentive to ties, reciprocities, and acts of care (Greer, 2021:235), providing for ‘sustainable development rather than unsustainable growth’ (Walmsley et al, 2022:68). Measuring the ‘soft’ social benefits of artists’ contributions to communities and people’s lives over a life cycle counters assertions that wastage of many artists’ talents through policy acceptance of manufactured scarcity is desirable and inevitable (Banks, 2022). 

The polar-opposite perspectives on sustainable arts development strategies identified by this study extend to ideas for scoping future financing. On one hand, ‘top-downer’ What Next? advocates for increased public funding from government to continue to be filtered down in England through ACE as the national arm’s length arts agency. Notably while ACE’s 2021-24 strategy to increase support to individuals acknowledges the imperfections of ‘trickle down’, it remains heavily reliant on existing organisations delivering training and development opportunity for freelancers (ACE, 2021). On the other hand, those identified in this study with ‘bottom up’ perspectives look to subsidiarity as route to growing localised arts economies. Such propositions for new structural and financial models to rebalance arts provision resonate with other advocacy for ‘levelling up’ arts and cultural provision (Cooper, 2020: 28), including through ‘place-based working’ that fosters ‘diverse cultural ecosystems’ (Walmsley et al, 2022:66).

Arguments for enhanced funding to local-specific frameworks align with related studies identifying the dysfunctionality of existing mechanisms that attempt to manage local policy from the centre (Sleaford et al, 2020; Walmsley et al, 2022). In particular, devolving ‘national’ arts funding to local authorities provides a strategic policy counter to London and urban-centric national strategies, prioritising arts resources for ‘those who need [them] the most, particularly smaller organisations and freelancers’ (Cooper, 2020: 5). Supported by enhanced powers and funding, making decisions affecting the local at that level fosters democratic responsibility and accountability. While challenging current assumptions about what constitutes difference, deprivation and discrimination, new systems in which local authorities set targets and resource levels for productivity, inclusivity and sustainability propose remedies for resource inequalities within socially disparate regions (Sleaford et al, 2020: 4-6) and are applicable to the arts freelance workforce.

Equitable distribution of the ‘national’ arts funding pot assumes retention or increased government grant-in-aid and National Lottery vired through ACE, which in the current political context there is no guarantee. Emerging sectoral ideas for augmenting arts funding include Manchester Museums Partnership’s Inquiry proposal for new city and regional tourist taxes to resource future place-specific arts and cultural development, and national enhancement of Museums and Galleries Exhibition Tax Relief (CVAN, 2019). In terms of bringing hitherto untapped resources into the arts, levying a UK art market transaction tax could bring £1b for redistribution as arts grant-in-aid by regionally representative, democratic bodies that prioritise ‘investment in people over products, process not results’ (Manifesto for Cultural Democracy, 2018). 

A tithe on empty property to create a Commons Fund offers a redistributable wealth resource for hyper-local developments and community resilience (Standing, 2018). Regardless of whether new revenue sources can be secured for the arts, the pandemic has called into question the future efficacy of a national agency making and delivering arts policy ‘top down’ and allocating the lion’s share of funding to permanent institutions whose ‘coercive patronage economy’ undermines freelancers’ sustainability (Greer, 2021:237). By demonstrating and contextualising sharpened interest across broader arts constituencies for forging granular, particularised, localised ecologies, this study reasserts the well-being of individuals as of equal significance (Woodley et al, 2018:11). 

Putting the focus on, and investment in, sustained interaction with place-based communities of interest proposes new opportunity for the arts to enhance the lives and well-being of citizens. This extends to identifying fresh platforms and processes for enabling very many artists to amplify their contributions to the arts, communities and society, while securing their individual resilience over a life cycle.

Bibliography 

Arts Council England (2010) Achieving Great Art for Everyone: a Strategic Framework for the Arts. London: Arts Council England.

Arts Council England (2021) Increasing our support to individuals [Accessed 17th September, 2021]

Banks, M (2017) Creative Justice: Cultural industries, work and inequality. London: Roman & Littlefield. 

Banks, M (2022) Cultural work and contributive justice. Journal of Cultural Economy. DOI: 10.1080/17530350.2022.2058059.

Banks, M and Hesmondhalgh, D (2009) Looking for work in creative industries policy. International Journal of Cultural Policy, 15(4): 415-430.

Belfiore, E (2021) Who cares? At what price? The hidden costs of socially engaged arts labour and the moral failure of cultural policy. European Journal of Cultural Studies, 25(1):61-78. 

Bernard, M, Comunian R, and Gross J (2021) Cultural and creative ecosystems: a review of theories and methods, towards a new research agenda. Cultural Trends DOI 10.1080/09548963.2021.2004073.

Burns, S (2017) Supporting the self-employed artist as Citizen: Looking up, looking down, looking around and looking forward. London: Winston Churchill Memorial Trust.

CAMEO (2019) It takes a region to raise an artist. Leicester: University of Leicester. 

Capra, F (2004) ‘Living networks’. In McCarthy, H. Miller P., and Skidmore P. (eds). Network Logic: who governs in an interconnected world? London: Demos: 25-34. 

Centre for Cultural Value (2020) Policy review: Social security for cultural practitioners https://www.culturehive.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2020/11/Policy-Review-Social-Security-for-Cultural-Practitioners.pdf [https://www.culturehive.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2020/11/Policy-Review-Social-Security-for-Cultural-Practitioners.pdf]

Comunian R and England L (2020) Creative and cultural work without filters: Covid-19 and exposed precarity in the creative economy. Cultural Trends 29:112-128

Connor, B (2021) Gender & creativity: progress on the precipice, special edition, UNESCO.

Cooper, B (2020) Cultured Communities: The crisis in local funding for arts and culture. London: Fabian Society.

CVAN (2020) Visual Arts: the beating heart and soul of building back better. https://cvan.art/visual-arts-the-beating-heart-and-soul-of-building-back-better/ [https://www.policyconnect.org.uk/research/visual-arts-beating-heart-and-soul-building-back-better] 

CVAN (2021) Impact of the Pandemic on the Livelihood of Visual Arts Workers 

Dutton, V (2021) Studio Practice Fund Part One: Discussion April 2021. London: Acme

Editorial, The Guardian view on saving the arts: what about the artists? 14 October 2020. 

Eikhof, D (2020) COVID-19, inclusion and workforce diversity in the cultural economy: what now, what next?. Cultural Trends, 29:3, 234-250, DOI:10.1080/09548963.2020.1802202

Florida, R (2002) The Rise of the Creative Class. New York: Basic Books

Galloway, S. Lindley, R., Davies R. and Scheibl, F (2002) A Balancing Act: artists’ labour markets and the tax and benefits system. London: Arts Council of England

Greer, S (2021) Funding resilience: market rationalism and the UK’s “mixed economy” for the arts. Cultural Trends. 30:3, 222-240

Gross, J and Wilson, N (2019) Creating the environment: The cultural ecosystems of Creative People and Places. Creative People and Places Network

Hark, S and Villa, P (2020) The future of difference: beyond the toxic entanglement of racism, sexism and feminism. London: Verso

Henry, N, Barker, V. Sissons, P, Broughton, K, Dickson, P, Lazell, J and Angus, T (2021) Mind the Understanding Gap: The Value of Creative Freelancers. Coventry: Coventry University Research Centre 

Holden, J (2015) Ecology of Culture: Report for the AHRC Cultural Values Project. Swindon: Arts and Humanities Research Council 

House of Commons (2020) Impact of COVID-19 on DCMS sectors: First Report 20 July 2020

Jackson, T. and Jordan, M. (2005) Review of the Presentation of the Contemporary Visual Arts Report: Part 1 Analysis & recommendations. London: Arts Council England

Jones, S (2019) Artists’ livelihoods: the artists in arts policy conundrum. PhD thesis, Manchester Metropolitan University

Jones, S (2020) Artists’ emergency: arts policy’s role in the future of artists’ livelihoods.

Louise, D (2011) Ladders for development: a-n Research paper. Newcastle: a-n The Artists Information Company

Manifesto for Cultural Democracy. 

Markusen, A, Gadwa, A Barbour, E, and Beyers, W (2011) California’s Arts and Cultural Ecology

New Art West Midlands (2019) No Limits: A Visual Arts Strategy for the West Midlands 2020-2025. Birmingham: Birmingham School of Art

Redmond, A (2021) ACE restricts eligibility for key funding streams, Arts Professional

Seaford, C, Glover B, Collinson, S, Hoole, C, Kitsos, A, Gutierrez Posada, D, Tilley H, Mukherjee A, Gilbert N, Newman J and Driffield N (2020) Achieving Levelling-Up: The Structures and Processes Needed, LIPSIT Report.

Siepel, J, Ospina J V, Camerani, R, Bloom M, Masucci, M and Casadei, P (2021) Creative Radar; The Impact of COVID-19 on the UK’s creative industries. London: PEC.

Standing, G. (2018) ‘Rentier Capitalism and the Precariat: The Case for a Commons Fund’. In McDonnell, J. (ed.) Economics for the Many. London & Brooklyn: Verso. pp. 195-206.

TBR (2018a) Livelihoods of Visual Artists: Summary Report. London: Arts Council England

TBR (2018b) Livelihoods of Visual Artists: 2016 Data Report. London: Arts Council England 

Walmsley, B, Gilmore, A, O’Brien, D and Torregiani, A (2022) Culture in Crisis: Impacts of Covid-19 on the UK Cultural sector and where we go from here. Centre for Cultural Value 

Woodley, S, Towell, P, Turpin, R, Thelwall, S, Schneider, P. (2018). What is Resilience Anyway? A Review, Arts Council England.