Artists’ pandemic stories
The government and Arts Council England’s exclusive and short-term emergency arts funding schemes for freelancers failed to address visual artists’ livelihood needs and allowed the majority to fall through the cracks.
Evidence from a new qualitative, longitudinal study that surprisingly demonstrates how the lives and artistic prospects of many artists positively improved in pandemic conditions offers clues to the infrastructural shifts needed to honour and sustain the talents and vibrancy of the diverse artists’ constituency in future.
Prologue
Resolving artists’ poor economic and social status has bedevilled arts policymaking in England for decades (Jones, 2019). Despite strategic national schemes such as Exhibition Payment Right running 1979-99 and Year of the Artist in 2000 intended to effect substantial and lasting change, artists’ incomes have remained uncomfortably lower than average national salaries (Brighton et al, 1985; Shaw and Allen, 1996; Kretschmer, Singh, Bently and Cooper, 2011; TBR, 2018).
Artists’ Pay
In the pre-pandemic period, artists’ average annual income was £16,150 or 58% of average annual salaries, with art practices bringing in just £6,020, and just 7% of artists earning more than £20,000 (TBR, 2018). In terms of rewards for artists’ freelance work, the recommended artists’ day rate was £262 (a-n, 2019) and a four-month socially engaged commission with the National Trust supported by Arts Council England (ACE) was £9,000 with additional travel and production budgets.
Artists’ principal economic challenge is poor financial return from art practices. Even when well into high visibility careers, artists who are externally judged to be ‘successful’ can remain dependent on a succession of insecure part-time teaching contracts with eroding terms and conditions (Burrows, 2022). Root causes of artists’ economic precarity are a combination of exceptional levels of unpaid speculative working necessary (Jones, 2019), the ongoing expense of maintaining art practices (TBR, 2018) and the unique vulnerability of freelance and portfolio working patterns (Wallis and Raalte, 2020).
This persistent financial hardship undermines artists’ self-esteem and sense of artistic continuity (Dutton, 2021a). Livelihood prospects are constrained by the protectionist, mysterious ways of contemporary visual arts infrastructures which restrict who become an artist in the first place as well as their ability to get ahead on merit. By treating artists predominantly as outsourced providers of cheap, just-in-time services, arts norms have the effect of undermining artists’ emotional strength and social position, affecting their ability to pursue and make a living from art practices over a life cycle. Structural over-dependency on intermediaries and gatekeepers and the preference for selecting artists on recommendation rather than though open calls make for vicarious careers.
‘There are curators who get to recommend artists for the ‘closed’ bursaries and commissions, you know, that only artists who are invited can apply for. Obviously, they don’t want hundreds and hundreds of applications to look at, but I do worry that it makes everything about their taste in artists.’
There’s a tendency for commissioners and curators to control artists’ futures by discouraging them from ‘showing too early’ and from presenting and selling work in the ‘wrong’ kinds of places such as from studios and at self-organised fairs. Artists are expected to ‘edit’ their behaviours and CVs to conform to these sensibilities, and to act as passive creatures willing to wait unspecified periods of time for gatekeeper acknowledgement (Morgan and Nelligan, 2015). It’s certainly ‘not cool’ for artists to be ‘difficult’ (McRobbie, 2002) or assertive about money.
‘[I suggested] we could we have some sort of workshop in between performances but quickly realised that I’m offering more free work here, but … I’d already said it and they .. were like, “Yeah,” but then no money was suggested. ….’.
Pandemic data analysis
According to quantitative data, visual artists suffered the worst economically amongst all arts freelancers in the pandemic period. Three quarters were ineligible for the government’s self-employed SEISS funding (Dutton, 2021a) whereas only a third of musicians were in this position. Median income loss was 60-80% (Dutton, 2021a), with 70% of visual arts workers experiencing an income drop, 28% losing £5,000-£10,000 and a further third losing over £10,000 (CVAN/Earthen Lamp, 2022). An ACE survey in June 2020 concluded that nearly half of individual artists wouldn’t be able to survive in the long term without ‘major interventions’.
Research method
The arts sector relies predominantly on quantitative data to scope policy development and measure social impacts but it’s a blunt instrument if the intention is to truly understand the causes of freelancers’ precarities and deliver structural interventions on equity and inclusivity grounds. The intention of an independent qualitative study conducted February-December 2021 is to put some flesh on these statistical bones. It provides alternative insights into pandemic impacts by capturing the social realities of thirteen artists from two areas in England and illuminating their approaches to sustaining art practices and livelihoods at a time of great social and economic upheaval. Use of in-depth, one-to-one interviews as research method enables these individuals to ‘make their own meanings and characterise their experiences in their own terms’ (Gill, 2007). The commonality amongst artists studied is that they each hold ‘professional-level expertise’ through making consistent, developmental and effortful progression over time within art practices (Bennett, 2013) including achievement of a ‘recognisable’ style (Smith, 2010).
This study benefits from a longitudinal dimension that is lacking as far as development and evaluation of cultural policy is concerned (Holden, 2004). Longitudinal study is vital to scoping interventions that directly support practices and improve people’s lives. By illuminating artists’ contrasting pandemic experiences, the research contributes both to understanding causes and consequences of failure amongst creative individuals (Hanage et al, 2016) and to identifying features in an inclusive arts ecology that captures artists’ multiple benefits to society and is supportive of their sustainability over a life cycle.
Part 1: ‘Covid is one of the best things that’s ever happened to me’
For most artists interviewed, the degree of artistic replenishment achieved during 2020-21 was unprecedented. Artists talked about pandemic circumstances as a unique opportunity to ‘hunker down’, buy materials and engross themselves in making work without the worry of showing and selling. In this period of ‘quiet time’ and reflection artists were able to ‘take the foot off the accelerator’. They rekindled art practices by incubating and ‘played around with ideas’, they felt ‘refilled’ by ‘seeing things through new lenses’. Artists not only gained new skills and amplified tacit knowledge through self-directed professional development and training – in one case ‘the best they’d ever done’ – but built artistic agency through heightened self-esteem and confidence. Liberated from having to ‘justify every little thing’ to art world systems and gatekeepers, artists drew on their inner strength and convictions to pursue their long-standing artistic and social preoccupations.
Artists’ vigorous application to the process of making work was matched by their greater willingness to ‘share it more openly on social media’. Use of virtual platforms for communications, delivering art activities to others and selling work was not only supportive of artists’ personal well-being and family circumstances but also provided vital access support to artists with visible and invisible disabilities including clinical vulnerability and chronic conditions including those shielding (Jones and Roy, 2020). More prosaically, artists’ health improved from doing more walking, swimming, running and gardening and spending less time travelling and schmoozing. Precious extra time with family was a ‘gift’ which when combined with locating art practices within more defined communities of interest, enabled artists to ‘slow down’ … and hear things you couldn’t before’. Pandemic circumstances that released artists from constraints of traditional environments proved an impetus for progressing art practices and relationships in new directions. Artists seized the luxury of unexpected time and space to seek out settings and collaborations more closely attuned to their social values. By positioning their lives and practices within wider social, cultural and environmental concerns including special educational needs and climate change, artists became more active in discourses beyond the narrowness of art world.
Time and money for R&D was a key factor in artistic replenishment. Artists recounted the pandemic period not only as when they had ‘evolved a style’, ‘built a reputation’ and moved their arts practices ‘up a whole notch’ but also the pivot for devising strategies to hold onto the more personalised development space they had forged in the period beyond. They derived artistic satisfaction and well-being from refreshing their communities of interest and social perspectives. One artist experienced a major artistic ‘breakthrough’ in these unusual conditions which ‘pushed’ them to collaborate with an organisation with whom they’d never before considered working. Although initially perceived as a major stumbling block, artists who had ‘pushed and fought’ their way around pandemic conditions were ‘proud’ and felt stronger as a result.
In contrast to the quantitative evidence described earlier on, in many cases pandemic conditions had the effect of reducing artists’ economic precarity. Cost-of-living and overhead savings from little or no travelling for work, eating out and less professional networking meant that many artists didn’t ‘struggle for money’. For gallery-focused artists, sales income was two and sometimes three times higher than a normal year, with the added benefit of no gallery sales commission deducted. Instagram proved an artists’ livelihoods star by enabling artists to show and sell their work in its best light and promote and validate live performance and digital practices. Matthew Burrows’ Artists’ Support Pledge (ASP) invaluably ‘legitimised’ selling direct from artists’ own studios, although the £200 maximum price was too low for some artists who used social media platform apps and promotional tools to reach and sell direct to domestic collectors.
For some artists with a consistent self-employment pattern the combination of pandemic financial support measures including small business support grants, the self-employed income support scheme (SEISS) and ACE emergency funding increased annual income by as much as 30%. Of all emergency measures, the government’s £10,000 small business support grants were the most valuable to artists in individual and collective studios. Distributed through local authorities, these grants effectively provided artists with an unprecedented level of ‘no strings’ R&D for artistic replenishment. For one artist, this non-competitive, non means tested grant put them ‘in a position I've never been in before. I could decide on work I wanted to make, but also make it with no restrictions …. the security that came from it put things in a different perspective.’
Part 2 – ‘I’m falling through the cracks’
Pandemic conditions were economically debilitating and emotionally exhausting for a smaller section of the interview cohort, highlighting overall lack of awareness of amongst funders, employers and advocates of the nuance of freelance conditions and of ‘honest conversations in the arts about money and how people make a living’. A typical income pattern for an artist is 33% from sales, 29% teaching, 16% cultural freelancing, 13% non-arts work, 5% grants and 4% from cultural employment (Acme, 2020). Artists’ incomes comprise self-employed aspects including fees for one-off commissions and exhibitions, employment through teaching and gallery education, casual and zero-hour contracts for community and participatory arts residencies and elements of non-art related work. However, the underlying assumption for SEISS and ACE’s emergency funds that visual artist claimants could earn 50% from self-employment failed to acknowledge this complexity. Others excluded from accessing SEISS payments included artists with breaks in self-employment for maternity leave and post-graduate study and others constituted as limited company directors whose income combines PAYE and annual dividends on profits. Although eligible, some artists were advised not to claim SEISS payments as these wouldn’t ‘look good’ on mortgage applications.
The contemporary visual arts environment implicitly discourages artists from negotiating conditions compatible with their particular social and economic circumstances. It’s ‘almost taken for granted’ in the pay and fees offered for artistic opportunity that artists have ‘some kind of underlying support’, such as from a partner or family. Organisations which already ‘know what they want’ and who treat artists like a ‘commodity’, ‘brought in’ to ‘fulfil a task’ once the staff ‘have done all the creative thinking’ offer artists neither artistic replenishment and opportunity to use their creative thinking nor economic security over a life cycle. Pandemic examples of the structural incompatibility between institutions’ expectation of freelancers and the reality of their lives include a commissioner who resolved a pandemic ‘budget shortage’ by a 25% cut to the artist’s fee, and a university offering an experienced artist-lecturer less for a fixed-term contract than they’d been paid fourteen years ago.
The nature of creative practices makes them highly attractive to neurodivergent (ND) individuals, hence higher levels of ADHD, bipolarity and autism amongst creative practitioners than in the wider population (Jowlett, 2021). Although they gain exceptional artistic stimulus from the ‘creative bit and the fun bit’, artists struggle to manage the high levels of emotional stress and ‘the mania which can go either way, and the … ‘darker bit, the dips and self-destructive bits’. Pandemic conditions that affected artists’ ‘general mood and mental health’ made such symptoms ‘increasingly more obvious’. It was ‘exhausting’ trying to navigate the mysterious, tightly defined contemporary visual arts environment. They were ‘sick of the competition [levels]’ and of always ‘having to justify who I am and what I do’. Artists remained committed to making ‘ambitious’ work without ‘having a breakdown’ but suffered from lack of nuanced, personalised support, for example to deal with application ‘paperwork’ that was ‘just too complicated’ and ‘not geared towards individual artists’.
Finding freedom
Initial analysis of data from this new study concludes that the social and economic shock of a worldwide pandemic was surprisingly ‘good’ for those artists who had already achieved consistent and developmental practices. The extraordinary conditions that provided a period of self-determined intense artistic experimentation and productivity had the effect of strengthening artists’ capacity to make ‘effortful progression’ within art practices. Close-down of the hyper-competitive contemporary visual arts infrastructure gave them unprecedented freedom to focus down on art practices and as a result, to improve their social and economic position over the longer-term. The unexpected luxury of time and ‘no strings’ financial resources enabled artists to realign and centre their practices and to ‘creat[e] meaningful work that parallels all that is important in your life’ (Summerton, 1996). These novel, fecund circumstances were impetus for artists to test out new, productive relationships with like-minded people locally and virtually and scope future avenues for mutuality and social interaction. Fuelling their intrinsic drive to pursue art practices for their own sake, pandemic conditions contributed to artists’ resilience through creating both human and economic reserves. They gained unique opportunity to ‘practice being human together’, this as antidote to cultural norms that ‘push’ individuals, commissioners and funders to think of people only as ‘markets, customers, providers or material’ (Robinson, 2021).
Artists’ continuous practices extend far beyond the immediate, recognisable and measurable outcomes made visible and quantified through public institutions and spaces. These encompass processes and actions in ‘whole cycles …. that go from feeling about where they're going to go next, to trying things out [until] something emerges’ (Tan, 2021). The massive social and economic shock of the pandemic proved to be an unlikely supporter of that cycle. The combination of intrinsically held beliefs and social values and the processes of artistic ‘refilling’ made the intense emotions and anxieties inherent in social upheaval manageable and formed into a ‘human reserve’ for artists akin to the financial reserves that cushion arts institutions against times of stress. This human reserve for artists is formed from the particularities of their practices (Virani and Orrù, 2021), arises from their persistence in the ‘creativity of undergoing’ (Smith, 2010, Ingold, 2014), an ’innate self-reflexivity and adaptability’ (Bradshaw, 2019) and the autonomy to ‘take chances’ (Dutton, 2021b). Artists’ pursuit of livelihoods through art practices over time is dependent on their ability to realise their assets including their tangible and intangible reserves combined with holding the agency to exercise and capitalise on their rights.
Achieving universal resilience stretches beyond the pursuit and implementation of self-protectionist measures within higher arts echelons. The pandemic’s unexpected positive impacts on artists’ practices and livelihoods offers clues towards how to better understand and acknowledge artists’ social value through adoption of regenerative practices and infrastructural solutions that are supportive of individual resilience over a life cycle. By highlighting artists’ socially and environmentally aware localised processes and practices premised on shared values, this study evidences a healthy shift at the arts grassroots to regenerative practices. By fostering a ‘human culture that is healthy, resilient and adaptable, cares for the planet and cares for life in awareness’ it is these new practices that offer the equity and inclusion the visual arts aspires to and ‘the most effective way to create a thriving future’ (Wahl, 2016).
© Susan Jones 2022
Credits
This research study would not have been possible without the artists whose active engagement and continued enthusiasm to take part in interviews since 2017 is appreciated and valued highly. Thanks also to CAMP for commissioning some additional interviews, a virtual presentation with interactive elements and this text published as Telling tales: artists’ pandemic stories.
References
a-n The Artists Information Company (2019) Guidance on fees and day rates for artists 2019
Acme (2020) Submission to the DCMS Inquiry into the impact of Covid-19 on its sectors
Bennett, S (2013) ‘Craftsperson, Hobbyist or Micro-Enterprise: The rise of the Pro-C Artist in the periphery regions of Mid and West Wales. Paper presented at RSA Annual Conference. Tampere, Finland. 5-8 May 2013
Bradshaw, A (2019) Resilience is futile. YVAN and Corridor 8
Brighton, A, Parry J and Pearson N M (1985) Enquiry into the Economic Situation of the Visual Artist. London: Calouste Gulbenkian Foundation
Burrows, W (2022) Notes on Class and the Contemporary Arts: Class IS A Big Deal. The Double Negative. https://www.thedoublenegative.co.uk/2019/01/notes-on-class-and-the-contemporary-arts-class-is-a-big-deal
CEBR (2017) Contribution of the arts and culture industry to the UK economy
Dutton, V (2021a) Studio Practice Fund Part One: Analysis April 2021. London: Acme
Dutton, V (2021b) Studio Practice Fund Part Two: Discussion April 2021. London: Acme
Hanage, R Scott, J and Davies, M (2016) ‘From “great expectations” to “hard times”: a longitudinal study of creative graduate new ventures.’ International Journal of Entrepreneurial Behavior & Research. 22:1. Emerald Publishing Group Ltd
Holden, J (2004) Capturing Cultural Value. London: Demos
Ingold, T (2014) ‘The creativity of undergoing’. Pragmatics & Cognition, 22(1). pp.124-139
Kretschmer, M, Singh, S, Bently, L and Cooper, E (2011) Copyright contracts and earnings of visual creators: A survey of 5,800 British designers, fine artists, illustrators and photographers. Bournemouth: Bournemouth University & Cambridge: University of Cambridge
Jones, S (2019) Artists’ livelihoods: the artists in arts policy conundrum, Ph.D. Manchester Metropolitan University.
Jones, S. (2020) The chance to dream: why give funding to individual artists? Research paper. Newcastle: a-n The Artists Information Company
Jones, S and Roy, V (2020) ‘Could do better: the exceptional impact of COVID19 emergency measures on visual artists with chronic conditions’. Conference paper, Another artworld is possible, December 2020
Jowlett, P (2021) ‘Neurodivergence manifesto a ‘call for change’’, Arts Professional.
Morgan, G and Nelligan, P (2015) ‘Labile labour – gender, flexibility and creative work’. The Sociological Review, 63:S1 pp.66-83
Robinson, M (2021) Tactics for the tightrope: creative resilience for creative communities. Future Arts Centres
Shaw, P and Allen, K (1996) Artists’ Rights Programme: A review of artists’ earnings for exhibitions and commissions: Executive Summary. London: National Artists Association
Slater, A, Ravetz, A and Lee, K (2013) Analysing Artists’ CPD. Manchester: Castlefield Gallery Publications
Smith, K M (2010) In Momentum: The Navigation, Narration, and Negotiation of Continuing Professional Development by Mid-Career Artists in South West England. Ph.D. University of Plymouth
Summerton, J (1996) ‘Mechanics and Metaphysics: empowerment and the artist’. In Summerton, J and Moody, E (eds). The Business of Being an Artist. London: City University.
Tan, J (2021) Desire lines: Liveability. Manchester: Proforma
TBR (2018) Livelihoods of Visual Artists. London: Arts Council England
Wahl, C W (2016) Designing Regenerative Cultures, Axminster: Triarchy Press
Wallis R and Van Raalte, C (2020) Growing a sustainable workforce: submission to the DCMS Inquiry.
Virani, T and Orrù, V (2021) Business reliance and visual art: New directions for research in business-oriented practice for visual artists. London: Space